The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutASRDRB20240111 6.1DESIGN REVIEW BOARD STAFF REPORT 6el TO: Design Review Board Members January 11, 2024 SUBJECT: Review and provide comments on the proposed Design Award categories and recommended nominees BACKGROUND The Town Council presents Design Awards to recognize architects, designers, and builders with outstanding designs in residential or commercial developments that exemplify and uphold the unique character of Danville. The design awards are presented periodically, as warranted, and were last presented during a regularly scheduled Town Council Meeting in March of 2020. DISCUSSION This year the Council has chosen the following Design Award categories: 1) Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design 2) Outstanding Custom Home Design 3) Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design 4) Outstanding Historic Renovation and Redevelopment Design Additional categories may be added if there are additional nominations that do not fall under a specific category. Project nominations are limited to developments completed within the years 2019-2023. Final nominations will be provided to the DRB in the January 11, 2024, meeting packet. DRB members should visit the sites and review the projects prior to the meeting. All DRB members' evaluations will be collectively reviewed during this meeting. The DRB will recommend potential Design Award recipients to the Town Council. The Town Council will select the winners at a study session on February 13, 2024, and the awards will be presented at a regularly scheduled Town Council Meeting in March of 2024. The following preliminary list includes all the new residential neighborhood design, custom home design, commercial remodel design, and historic renovation and redevelopment design projects that have been completed between 2019-2023. Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design: • Rivers Lane (80-88 Rivers Lane): 1485 Lawrence, LLC, Owner; The Address Company, Architect • 134 El Dorado Ave: Haven Development, Owner; William Hezmalhalch Architects, Architect • Edendale (southeast corner of Camino Tassajara and Sherburne Hills Road, Akabane Lane, Maple Lane, and Pine Place): Trumark Homes, LLC, Owner; SDG Architects, Architect • Hackler Court (80-89 Hackler Court): Kathy Blankenship, Owner; The Address Company, Architect • Julia Loop (100-130 Julia Loop): Landsea Homes Owner; William Hezmalhalch Architects, Architect Outstanding Custom Home Design: • 66 Sherburne Hills Road: Sandy Mann, Owner; Watkins Planning & Landscape Architecture, Architect • 372 Cordell Drive: Dimitrios and Nikki Haramoglis, Owners; Westward Atelier, Architect Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design: • Taco Bell (444 Front Street): Scarbrough Management Co., Owner; Globeatelie, Architect • I Can Do That! Performing Arts Center (194 Diablo Road): Marcus Madrid, Owner; Barry & Wynn Architects, Applicant • 200 Hartz Ave Shopping Center: Silvio Quattro, Owner; FCGA Architects, Architect • The Fazzio/Fischer House (344 Railroad Ave), Todd and Kristin Fitch, Owner; Barry and Wynn Architects, Architect Outstanding Historic Renovation and Redevelopment Design: • Jewelers Building (375 Hartz Ave): John and Sharon DeSousa, Owner; Barry and Wynn Architects, Architect Design Awards 2 January 11, 2024 RECOMMENDATION Provide comments on the proposed Design Award categories and recommended nominees. Prepared by: AUE5 Riley Anderson -Barrett Associate Planner Attachment: Design Award Packet Design Awards 3 January 11, 2024 Town of Danville 2024 Design Awards Recognizing Outstanding Architectural Design Design Review Board Members Mark Belotz Robert Combs Afshan Hamid Lous Palandrani Chris Trujillo Kevin Wong Judging Criteria and Scoring Criteria Each entry will be judged for the success with which the project meets the intent and requirements of the Towri s General Plan, Climate Action Plan, ordinances, and adopted design standards. Each nominee will be evaluated and scored on the following criteria (scale of 0-10, where 10 is the best): 1) Project Configuration and Layout (0-10 points) 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community (0-10 points) 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting (0-10 points) 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements (0-10 points) 5) Landscaping and Entries (0-10 points) 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques (0-10 points) 7) Renewable Sources of Energy (0-10 points) Total Points: 0 to 70 Points 2024 Design Award Nominees This year the Council has chosen the following Design Award categories: 1) Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design 2) Outstanding Custom Home Design 3) Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design 4) Outstanding Historic Renovation and Redevelopment Design Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design: • Rivers Lane (80-88 Rivers Lane): 1485 Lawrence, LLC, Owner; The Address Company, Architect • 134 El Dorado Ave: Haven Development, Owner; William Hezmalhalch Architects, Architect • Edendale (southeast corner of Camino Tassajara and Sherburne Hills Road, Akabane Lane, Maple Lane, and Pine Place): Trumark Homes, LLC, Owner; SDG Architects, Architect • Hackler Court (80-89 Hackler Court): Kathy Blankenship, Owner; The Address Company, Architect • Julia Loop (100-130 Julia Loop): Landsea Homes Owner; William Hezmalhalch Architects, Architect Category 2: Outstanding Custom Home Design: • 66 Sherburne Hills Road: Sandy Mann, Owner; Watkins Planning & Landscape Architecture, Architect • 372 Cordell Drive: Dimitrios and Nikki Haramoglis, Owners; Westward Atelier, Architect Category 3: Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design: • Taco Bell (444 Front Street): Scarbrough Management Co., Owner; Globeatelie, Architect • I Can Do That! Performing Arts Center (194 Diablo Road): Marcus Madrid, Owner; Barry & Wynn Architects, Applicant • 200 Hartz Ave Shopping Center: Silvio Quattro, Owner; FCGA Architects, Architect • The Fazzio/Fischer House (344 Railroad Ave), Todd and Kristin Fitch, Owner; Barry and Wynn Architects, Architect Category 4: Outstanding Historic Renovation and Redevelopment Design: • Jewelers Building (375 Hartz Ave): John and Sharon DeSousa, Owner; Barry and Wynn Architects, Architect Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design Nominee: Rivers Lane (80-88 Rivers Lane) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design Nominee:134 El Dorado Ave 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design Nominee: Edendale 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design Nominee: Hackler Court (80-89 Hackler Court) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 1: Outstanding New Residential Neighborhood Design Nominee: Julia Loop (100-130 Julia Loop) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 2: Outstanding Custom Home Design Nominee: 66 Sherburne Hills Road 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 2: Outstanding Custom Home Design Nominee: 372 Cordell Drive I 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: r- '.1 (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 3: Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design Nominee: Taco Bell (444 Front Street) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 3: Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design Nominee: I Can Do That! Performing Arts Center (194 Diablo Road) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 3: Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design Nominee: 200 Hartz Ave Shopping Center 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 3: Outstanding Commercial Remodel Design Nominee: The Fazzio/Fischer House (344 Railroad Ave) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) Category 4: Outstanding Historic Renovation and Redevelopment Design Nominee: Jewelers Building (375 Hartz Ave) 1) Project Configuration and Layout 2) Fitting into the Fabric of the Community 3) Colors, Materials and Lighting 4) Degree of Innovation - Exterior Design Elements 5) Landscaping and Entries 6) Energy Efficient or Green Building Techniques 7) Renewable Sources of Energy Total Points: 0 to 70 Points Notes: (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points) (0-10 points)